I have built both, for real businesses that are trading right now. So let me give you the answer I give on the phone, which is shorter than most articles on this and less flattering to my own invoice.
If you are selling physical products and you are not sure, use Shopify. That is the honest default for most small UK shops, and talking someone out of it to sell them something bigger is how this industry gets its reputation.
What follows is when that default is wrong.
What you are actually choosing between
This is not really "Shopify versus custom". A custom-looking store on Shopify is a normal, sensible thing — it is what I built for The Card Republic and The Graded Gallery, and both look nothing like a default theme.
The real choice is who handles the plumbing: payments, stock counts, tax, shipping labels, refunds, chargebacks, PCI compliance, and the fraud check on the order that does not look right. Shopify does all of that for £25 a month. A custom build means someone builds it, and then someone maintains it, forever.
When Shopify is the right answer
You sell physical products in reasonably normal ways. Sizes, colours, stock levels, postage bands, a sale now and then. This is what the platform is for and it does it well.
You want to run it yourself. Adding a product, changing a price, starting a sale — all of it without needing a developer. That is worth more than most design flourishes.
Your budget is under about £3,000. Below that figure a custom store means cutting corners on the parts you cannot see, which are the parts that cost you money when they are wrong.
You want to sleep. Card data, fraud, and tax are genuinely somebody else's problem on Shopify. That is not a small thing.
When a custom build earns its money
Your process is not a normal shop. If something has to happen between the order and the dispatch that a shop platform does not understand — a made-to-measure step, a quote, an approval, an inspection — you will fight the platform forever. The Graded Gallery is exactly this: the store is Shopify, and the card-grading workflow behind it is a custom staff portal, because no shop platform models "customer posts an irreplaceable item to a stranger and it moves through five stages".
You are not really selling online at all. If the site's job is to get enquiries rather than orders, a shop platform is the wrong shape and you are paying £25 a month for a checkout nobody uses.
The catalogue is enormous or comes from somewhere else. Thousands of lines synced from a supplier feed is a data problem, not a design one, and it usually needs building.
You have outgrown it. Genuine platform limits are real, but they arrive later than people think — usually well past the point where you can comfortably afford to solve them.
What each actually costs
- Shopify · from £350 to set up, £25/month to runA custom theme and full store configuration. Add about 2% + 25p per order in card fees. You own the store and can run it without me.
- Custom build · from £3,000, plus hostingWorth it when the process is genuinely unusual. Not worth it to avoid a £25 monthly fee — that maths takes about ten years to work.
- Both · Shopify plus something custom behind itMore common than people expect. The shop does the selling, a purpose-built tool does the bit the shop cannot.
The honest trade, stated plainly
Shopify costs you £300 a year and roughly 2% of everything you sell, forever. In exchange you never think about payment security, and you can hire anybody to work on it afterwards.
A custom store costs you more up front and nothing monthly to the platform, but every problem is now yours. Including the ones that arrive at 9pm on a Saturday in December.
For most small UK shops, the monthly fee is the better deal and it is not close. I say that as someone who would be paid considerably more to tell you otherwise.
If you are working out the whole cost of ownership, what a website costs to run has the full breakdown, and online shops is the page for the build side.
Common questions
Is Shopify worth it for a very small shop?
Usually yes. £25 a month is roughly one order for most businesses, and in exchange the platform handles payments, stock, tax and shipping labels without you. The alternative is either a marketplace taking a much larger cut, or building and maintaining that yourself. Shopify also has a cheaper Starter plan at around £5 a month, but it does not allow custom themes, so it is a stopgap rather than a shop.
Can a Shopify store look bespoke?
Yes. A theme built from scratch to your brand is a normal piece of work and the result looks nothing like a default store. What you cannot easily change is the checkout, which Shopify controls — and that is mostly a good thing, because it is the part that has to be secure.
When should I build a custom online shop instead?
When something has to happen between the order and the dispatch that a shop platform does not understand — a made-to-measure step, an approval, an inspection, a grading process. Or when the catalogue is very large and comes from a supplier feed. Wanting to avoid the monthly fee is not a good enough reason on its own.
What happens to my Shopify store if I stop working with my developer?
Nothing, as long as the account is in your name. That is the point of using a platform — the store keeps running, and you can hire anybody who knows Shopify to work on it. Always open the account yourself, on your own card.
Do I need Shopify if I only sell a handful of items?
Not necessarily. A few products can be sold through a simple payment link or a buy button on an ordinary website, which costs far less monthly. Shopify starts paying for itself once you have real stock to track, several product variants, or orders arriving faster than you want to process them by hand.