Most redesigns I am asked about are not really about design. Something changed — the business, the market, what customers expect — and the site stayed where it was. Here is how I work out whether a rebuild is the answer, including when it is not.
The business moved and the site did not. You sell something you did not sell three years ago, or you have stopped taking the work the site is still advertising. Every enquiry now starts with a correction. This one is usually fixable without a rebuild.
It was never built to be found. The site looks fine and nobody sees it. That is a structure and content problem rather than a design one, and redesigning it will change nothing about the traffic. I will tell you that rather than sell you a rebuild.
It has quietly fallen behind. Slow on a phone, awkward to use one-handed, a contact form that goes to an address nobody checks, a certificate warning, a plugin that broke in 2024. This is the common one, and it is the one where a rebuild genuinely pays.
The first question is always which of those three you have. Answering it takes me about twenty minutes and costs nothing, and roughly one time in four the honest answer is that a redesign is not what you need.
An honest look first. I go through what you have — how it is built, what it is doing well, what is broken, and whether the problem is design, structure, content or something outside the site entirely. You get that back in plain English whether or not you hire me.
Keeping what works. A rebuild that throws away pages already earning their keep is a rebuild that loses you ground. Anything ranking, anything converting, and every URL people have bookmarked or linked to gets carried across and redirected properly. A redesign that quietly drops half your pages is the most common way a new site performs worse than the old one.
Designed for one business, not a theme. Same as any build here — see what it costs.
Yours at the end. Domain and hosting in your name, files handed over. If you are not certain who owns your current site, check before you commission anything — it is the single most common thing that goes wrong with a rebuild, and it goes wrong before the work starts rather than during it.
Published rather than hidden behind a form. The full pricing page has what is in and out of each tier:
A ready-made theme with your details dropped in. Fine if the website is a formality — but it is the interchangeable look people scroll past.
A custom site designed around your business. Where most established local businesses should sit.
Where most landA proper store with products, payments and stock, built to be run by you rather than by a developer.
Optional. Hosting, updates, backups and small changes handled, so you never touch it unless you want to.
Shopify's own costs — £25 a month, about 2% and 25p per order — go to Shopify, not to me. Here is the whole running-cost picture.
Ask what specifically is failing. If it is the words, the prices or the services, that is an afternoon of edits. If it is slow, awkward on a phone, or built on something that has stopped being maintained, that is a rebuild. If nobody is finding it at all, redesigning will not change that and you should fix the structure and content first. I will give you my honest read before you commit to anything.
Not if the rebuild is done properly, and that is mostly about URLs. Every address that exists now either stays the same or gets a permanent redirect to its replacement. Pages that are ranking get carried across rather than quietly dropped. Sites that lose rankings in a redesign almost always lost them by changing every URL and redirecting nothing.
Depends what it is built on and how. Sometimes the right answer is to fix and extend what is there, which is cheaper for you. Sometimes what is there is holding everything back and rebuilding is faster than repairing. I will tell you which, and I would rather do the cheaper job well than the expensive one reluctantly.
From £1,500, same as any bespoke build, with the exact figure fixed in writing before anything starts. A redesign is sometimes less work than a new site because the content already exists, and sometimes more because untangling what is there takes longer than starting clean. The pricing page has every tier.
Usually two to four weeks from the point your content is ready, not from the point you pay. Gathering photos, copy and product details is almost always the slow part, so it is worth starting on that before you commission anything.
More common than it should be. You will need the domain and the hosting in your own name before anything can move. That is usually a friendly email; occasionally it is not. I have written up how to check where you stand and what to do if the answer is not good.
Send me the address of your current site and what is bothering you about it. I'll come back within a day, and I'll tell you if a redesign isn't the answer.
Start a project